Start with these three
- Thank every gift within two days, signed by a person.
- Pick one named person to own follow-up.
- Before December, list everyone who gave last year and hasn't this year.
Within 48 hours of a gift
- Send a thank-you within two days, signed by a real person.
Speed tells the donor the gift was noticed, not processed.
Watch for: A receipt is not a thank-you. Send both, or put a personal line on the receipt.
- Mention what the gift is for, in one sentence.
Donors give to a purpose, not to a general fund in their heads.
Watch for: Avoid "your generous support of our mission". Name the meal, the bed, the class.
- Log the gift and the thank-you on the donor's record the same day.
The next person who calls that donor needs to know it happened.
Watch for: If it isn't written down, it didn't happen when the staff member leaves.
- Thank in-kind donors and volunteers the same way.
They are often next year's cash donors.
Watch for: They're the ones most often forgotten, because no money moved.
Every month
- Pick one named person to own follow-up.
Shared jobs slip. One owner doesn't.
Watch for: "The team" is not an owner.
- List every gift from the last 30 days and check each was thanked.
It catches the ones that fell through a busy week.
Watch for: Do it on the same day each month, or it won't happen.
- Call three donors with no ask.
A call with nothing attached is the thank-you people remember.
Watch for: Keep it to two minutes and write one line on their record afterwards.
- Write down one thing a donor told you.
Their kids' names, why they give, what they care about. That's your relationship, on paper.
Watch for: If it lives only in your head, the next director starts from zero.
Before year-end
- Pull a list of everyone who gave last year and hasn't this year.
They are the easiest gifts you'll get. They already said yes once.
Watch for: Run it in October or November, not December 30th.
- Give each of them an owner and a short personal note.
A note from someone they know outperforms a mass appeal.
Watch for: Mention their last gift and what it did.
- Check your give page on a phone.
Most people give from a phone. A broken page loses the gift at the last step.
Watch for: Tap every button. Check the amount buttons and the confirmation email.
- Make it easy for donor-advised fund donors.
They need your legal name, EIN and mailing address.
Watch for: Put them on the give page, not buried in a PDF.
Board and relationships
- Ask every board member who they know.
Your network is wider than your donor list.
Watch for: Write the answers down in one shared place.
- When a board member leaves, hold an exit conversation.
You learn what's working and keep the relationships they brought.
Watch for: Ask who they'd introduce you to before they go.
If one of these keeps slipping
That's usually a sign the work depends on one person remembering. In a free listening session I'll hear how your follow-up runs now, then send a written proposal for the one fix that would take it off someone's plate, inside the database you already use.
Book a free listening sessionAbout 90 minutes. No obligation, and what you tell me stays between us. Or call or text (423) 451-6798.